Links

Amazon

Twitch

CRITIK

Sonic Mania

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Sonic Mania
Item: Sonic Mania
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2017

GenresAdventure, Action, Platformer, Old-School Style, Side View Perspective, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableAug 15, 2017

PlatformPC, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox One

DeveloperSegaSoft, Sega, PagodaWest Games

Overview

Experience the ultimate celebration of past and future in Sonic Mania! Re-live the Sonic of the past with an exciting new twist on classic zones while fighting against new bosses and Dr. Eggman’s evil robot army. Go head to-head with players in Competition Mode or play in Co-Op Mode with a friend.

Elsewhere

8.2

Game analysis

Critik Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

52%

Mixed (50-79)

48%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The critics generally praise Sonic Mania for its nostalgic and straightforward storyline that harkens back to the classic Sonic games. CGMagazine appreciates the brand new story that continues from Sonic 3, with short, voiceless cutscenes adding to the experience. GameGrin and PlayStation Country also commend the game for focusing on classic Sonic gameplay without unnecessary characters or backstories. Hardcore Gamer highlights the engaging story involving Doctor Eggman and a mysterious gem, setting the stage for Sonic's journey through familiar and new zones. TheXboxHub mentions the nostalgic and faithful storyline that sees Sonic and Tails investigating an anomaly and traveling through classic and new zones. The simplicity and familiarity of the plot seem to resonate positively with many critics, appealing to fans of the original Sonic games. On the other hand, some critics find fault in the lack of depth and complexity in Sonic Mania's story. DualShockers notes that the game introduces a simple plot involving Dr. Eggman and Chaos Emeralds, prioritizing gameplay over narrative. ICXM also mentions the plot not being complex, focusing on stopping Doctor Eggman's schemes without delving into intricate storytelling. Gamers' Temple points out the lack of a compelling narrative, indicating that the story may not be a significant aspect for some players. While the straightforward nature of the story may appeal to those seeking a classic Sonic experience, it could be seen as a missed opportunity to explore more intricate plotlines or character development. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sonic Mania delivers a nostalgic and simple storyline that stays true to the roots of the original Sonic games. The game's focus on classic gameplay elements and familiar characters like Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Dr. Eggman resonates well with fans of the franchise. While some critics acknowledge the lack of depth in the narrative, the majority appreciate the game's ability to blend nostalgia with modern expectations. Critics like Metro GameCentral and PlayStation Universe find the rudimentary story effective in serving its purpose, offering a familiar setting with some twists. In conclusion, Sonic Mania's story may not be groundbreaking, but it effectively captures the essence of classic Sonic adventures, appealing to both longtime fans and newcomers to the series.

TL;DR

story and narrative

TL;DR Sonic Mania impresses critics with its nostalgic and straightforward storyline reminiscent of classic Sonic games, focusing on familiar characters and gameplay elements. While some critics find the plot lacking depth, most appreciate its blend of nostalgia and modern expectations, making it a hit among fans old and new.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

97%

Mixed (50-79)

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of Sonic Mania for successfully capturing the essence of the original Sonic games while introducing new elements to keep it fresh and engaging. Positive aspects highlighted by reviewers include the fast-paced running and jumping mechanics, responsive controls, and the inclusion of new abilities like the Drop Dash, which adds depth to the gameplay. Trusted Reviews commends the game for its smart and well-designed gameplay, while DualShockers appreciates the multiple routes and enjoyable level design that enhance the overall experience. Nintendo Life mentions the tight and immediately satisfying gameplay, with new features like co-op play and special stages adding additional challenges and replay value. On the downside, some critics pointed out certain issues with the gameplay of Sonic Mania. App Trigger and Windows Central mentioned frustrating design choices such as unfair enemy placements and punishingly hard bonus stages. Windows Central also noted that some new moves can be performed by mistake, leading to potential frustrations for players. GameSpot highlighted that while boss fights are challenging and diverse, there are instances of difficulty spikes that may not appeal to all players, especially newcomers to the series. Additionally, Digital Chumps mentioned that mastering the controls can be rewarding but also challenging due to the fast and janky movements of Sonic. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the gameplay of Sonic Mania. The game successfully blends classic Sonic elements with new additions, offering a nostalgic yet refreshing experience for both longtime fans and newcomers. Game Informer praises the preservation of the thrill of speeding through stages and discovering new routes, while GameWatcher applauds the precise controls and well-designed levels that contribute to the overall enjoyment of the gameplay. Despite some minor criticisms regarding difficulty spikes and control challenges, the majority of critics agree that Sonic Mania delivers a satisfying and engaging gameplay experience that honors the legacy of the iconic franchise while introducing innovative elements to keep players hooked.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics rave about Sonic Mania's gameplay for capturing classic Sonic feel with new twists like the Drop Dash. Praise for fast-paced mechanics, varied routes, and challenging boss fights. Some critique unfair enemy placements and control challenges, but overall, game offers nostalgic yet refreshing experience for fans and newcomers alike.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

90%

Mixed (50-79)

10%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The majority of critics were highly impressed with the graphics and visual design of Sonic Mania, praising its nostalgic charm and modern enhancements. Vooks from Vooks appreciated the visually stunning zones with vibrant colors and distinct vibes, blending retro-remix stages with entirely new ones. GameWatcher from GameWatcher commended the nostalgic visuals reminiscent of the Genesis/MegaDrive era, highlighting the imaginative and delightful levels with well-designed environments and bosses. Cubed3 from Cubed3 also lauded the vibrant and stylish levels with distinct visual aesthetics that enhance the pixel graphics, mentioning the widescreen format allowing for better reaction time. Despite the overwhelmingly positive reception, a few critics did not delve into detailed analysis or had minor criticisms regarding the graphics and visual design of Sonic Mania. For instance, Push Square from Push Square and Destructoid from Destructoid did not provide in-depth assessments of the visuals, focusing more on other aspects of the game. Trusted Reviews from Trusted Reviews also lacked specific details about the graphics or visual design, despite praising the game for replicating the aesthetic of the original Sonic games. These reviews suggest a lack of detailed critique in terms of the graphics, which could have offered a more comprehensive evaluation. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the graphics and visual design of Sonic Mania. Critics such as Game Informer and Game Over Online praised the stunning retro-inspired design, detailed sprite work, expanded color palette, and robust character animation. The game successfully captures the essence of the classic Sonic games while introducing modern touches and enhancements, blending old and new elements seamlessly. The visuals were commended for their attention to detail, vibrant environments, and nostalgic appeal, appealing to both long-time fans of the franchise and newcomers. The majority of critics found Sonic Mania to be a visually engaging and aesthetically pleasing experience that effectively balances nostalgia with modern enhancements, making it a standout title in the Sonic series.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics rave about Sonic Mania's graphics, applauding its nostalgic charm and modern enhancements. Visually stunning zones, imaginative levels, and well-designed environments earn high praise. Some critics lack in-depth analysis, but overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive. The game successfully blends retro aesthetics with modern touches, appealing to both longtime fans and newcomers. Sonic Mania stands out as a visually engaging and nostalgic title in the Sonic series.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

95%

Mixed (50-79)

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The majority of critics unanimously praised the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Mania, highlighting its exceptional quality and nostalgic appeal. Critics such as Worth Playing, who played on PS4, commended the game for seamlessly blending original sound effects and music from past titles with new compositions, enhancing the overall nostalgic feel of the gameplay. The Sydney Morning Herald, playing on NINTENDO SWITCH, noted that while the timeless funky music remained intact, there was also a new and energetic twist to it, with remixes of familiar theme songs. Additionally, GameSpot's review on XBOX ONE highlighted the vibrant '90s-inspired pop soundtrack with new music tracks and remixes that complemented the visuals and built a contemporary yet nostalgic aesthetic. On the flip side, a few critics pointed out minor issues with the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Mania. Polygon, playing on XBOX ONE, mentioned that while the game featured familiar sound effects and nostalgic music capturing the essence of the original Sonic games, some audio cues could be enraging. ZTGD, also on XBOX ONE, noted issues with the inability to change visual or sound options in-game, which could potentially hinder the player's experience. These criticisms, however, were overshadowed by the overwhelmingly positive reception from the majority of reviewers. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Sound Design and Music of Sonic Mania. The game's soundtrack, composed by Tee Lopes, was widely praised for capturing the classic Sonic spirit with a modern twist, enhancing the overall experience for players. Critics such as USgamer and Game Informer highlighted the stellar soundtrack, describing it as working seamlessly with the level design and expansions on the original formula. The majority of reviewers appreciated the nostalgic feel of the music, the energetic and toe-tapping tracks, and the remixes of classic tunes that added depth to the gameplay. Sonic Mania's Sound Design and Music were deemed as some of the best in the Sonic series in years, with critics like COGconnected praising the bombastic pop sounds and fleshed-out classic tunes that operated at full nostalgic capacity. In conclusion, Sonic Mania's Sound Design and Music received high acclaim from critics, solidifying its position as a standout aspect of the game that resonated well with fans of the franchise.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics rave about Sonic Mania's Sound Design and Music for its exceptional quality and nostalgic appeal. The game seamlessly blends original sounds with new compositions, creating a nostalgic yet modern vibe. While some critics noted minor issues like audio cues and limited options, the majority praised the soundtrack for capturing the classic Sonic spirit with a contemporary twist. Overall, Sonic Mania's Sound Design and Music are hailed as some of the best in the series, enhancing the gameplay experience and delighting fans with energetic tracks and nostalgic remixes.

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

48%

Mixed (50-79)

52%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of technical performance on the PS4 platform, Sonic Mania received positive feedback from critics. DualShockers praised the game for running at a smooth 60 fps and offering additional video settings like CRT TV mode. LaPS4 commended the game for its seamless 60 fps performance, responsive controls, and smooth movement for Sonic. Hobby Consolas also highlighted the smooth performance at 60 fps, indicating good technical performance. Overall, the PS4 version of Sonic Mania was well-received for its technical prowess and smooth animations. On the other hand, some negative aspects were pointed out by critics for the PS4 version of Sonic Mania. GameCrate mentioned issues with the save game system and instant deaths from being crushed, which could feel unfair to some players. PlaySense raised concerns about the autosave system only saving at the beginning of a zone, potentially disrupting the pacing of the game for some players. Despite these issues, the overall sentiment towards the technical performance on the PS4 platform was positive, with most critics praising the game for its smooth performance and lack of major technical issues. Across all gaming platforms, Sonic Mania generally received high praise for its technical performance. Critics like GameWatcher noted that the PC version ran perfectly with no performance issues reported. Forbes mentioned that both the Switch and PS4 versions ran very smoothly, while Nintendo Life highlighted the solid 60fps performance on the Nintendo Switch. Despite some minor glitches and occasional frame rate drops reported on different platforms, the overall consensus among critics was that Sonic Mania delivered a nostalgic and enjoyable gaming experience with solid technical performance. Critics like The Games Machine praised the game for its challenging gameplay and abundance of secrets, further solidifying its positive reception among reviewers.

TL;DR

technical performance

Sonic Mania impresses on the PS4 with smooth 60fps performance, but faces criticism for save system issues. Overall, the game receives high praise for technical performance, with minor glitches across different platforms not dampening the nostalgic and enjoyable gaming experience it offers.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

84%

Mixed (50-79)

16%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The majority of critics praised the replay value of Sonic Mania, highlighting various aspects that contribute to its high replayability. Positive points mentioned by reviewers include the presence of multiple playable characters with unique abilities, unlockable content such as special stages and bonus levels, and diverse gameplay modes like Time Attack and Competition. Critics like PlaySense, who appreciated the additional routes and characters, and Hardcore Gamer, who emphasized the multiple secrets and extras to discover, both acknowledged the game's ability to keep players engaged through its variety and incentives for replaying levels. The inclusion of nostalgic elements, such as all three iconic characters unlocked from the beginning, as noted by COGconnected, also adds to the game's appeal for fans of the classic Sonic games. On the downside, some critics noted certain issues that could affect the replay value of Sonic Mania. Shacknews mentioned that some later stages felt artificially frustrating, which could potentially deter players from revisiting those specific sections. Polygon highlighted the old-school retry system and frustrating boss encounters as factors that might impact the game's overall replayability. Additionally, App Trigger pointed out the lack of online play as a missed opportunity to enhance the replay value further, potentially limiting the multiplayer experience for some players. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the replay value of Sonic Mania. With a vast majority of reviewers expressing satisfaction with the game's ability to offer engaging and varied gameplay experiences that encourage multiple playthroughs, it is evident that Sonic Mania succeeds in providing a high level of replayability. Critics like Game Informer, who appreciated the multiple characters and branching paths, and GameSpot, who highlighted the additional modes and secrets for unlocking new content, contribute to the overall sentiment that Sonic Mania is a must-play title for fans of the franchise seeking a nostalgic yet fresh experience with substantial replay value. The blend of nostalgia and new gameplay elements, as mentioned by GamingTrend, further solidifies Sonic Mania's position as a game that caters to both old and new fans of the Sonic series, ensuring a long-lasting and enjoyable return to the beloved franchise for players of all backgrounds.

TL;DR

replay value

Sonic Mania's replay value shines with its diverse gameplay modes, unlockable content, and nostalgic elements, keeping players engaged through incentives and variety. Critics praise the game for offering engaging experiences and multiple playthroughs, despite some minor issues like frustrating stages and lack of online play. Overall, Sonic Mania is a must-play title for fans, blending nostalgia with new elements for a fresh and enjoyable experience with substantial replay value.

Overall Verdict

CRITIK

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Critik Score

Positive (80-100)

91%

Mixed (50-79)

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple reviewers on Sonic Mania, it is evident that the majority of critics had overwhelmingly positive feedback about the game. The game was praised for successfully capturing the essence of the classic Sonic games, with many reviewers commending its nostalgic gameplay, masterful level design, and faithful recreation of the original Sonic experience. Critics like COGconnected, Game Informer, and Game Over Online highlighted the pixel-perfect graphics, fantastic music, and challenging gameplay that made Sonic Mania a must-play for fans of the franchise. The addition of new elements and modes, as mentioned by MondoXbox, also contributed to enhancing the overall experience for players. On the flip side, some reviewers did point out a few drawbacks in Sonic Mania. TrueGaming mentioned disruptive boss battles and a limited save system as minor issues that affected the gameplay experience. Polygon also noted that while the game excelled in recreating classic Sonic gameplay, it fell short in addressing some recurring issues in the series. Despite these criticisms, the negative aspects were generally minor in comparison to the overall positive reception the game received from the critics. Overall, the consensus among the critics is overwhelmingly positive, with many considering Sonic Mania as a standout title in the Sonic series. Reviewers like GameSpot, Game Informer, and Worth Playing described the game as a return to form for the franchise, blending nostalgia with new ideas to create a memorable and enjoyable experience for both old and new fans. The game's ability to appeal to nostalgic fans while also introducing fresh elements was a common theme in the reviews, earning Sonic Mania high praise as one of the best Sonic games in years. The sentiment that Sonic Mania is a love letter to fans, a triumphant return-to-form, and a must-have for platforming enthusiasts further solidifies its position as a highly recommended title within the gaming community.

TL;DR

Sonic Mania received overwhelmingly positive feedback from critics for capturing the essence of classic Sonic games with nostalgic gameplay, masterful level design, and faithful recreation of the original experience. While some reviewers noted minor drawbacks like disruptive boss battles and limited save system, the game was hailed as a standout title in the Sonic series, blending nostalgia with new ideas to create a memorable experience for fans old and new. Overall, Sonic Mania is praised as a love letter to fans and a must-have for platforming enthusiasts.

CRITIK

Reviews

177 reviews found

100

Twinfinite

Nintendo Switch

Aug 16, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review gives Sonic Mania a score of 5/5, describing it as exemplary and one of the best 2D platformers of this generation and of all time, praising its nostalgic references and new entry feel.

Read full review

100

GameGrin

PlayStation 4

Sep 11, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Described as an outstanding return to form for Sonic, highly addictive and fun, and a must-have for platform game fans.

Read full review

100

TheSixthAxis

PlayStation 4

Aug 14, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania surpasses the Mega Drive/Genesis originals and sets the bar high for 2D platformers, appealing to both nostalgic fans and newcomers.

Read full review

100

The Sydney Morning Herald

Nintendo Switch

Aug 16, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review describes Sonic Mania as a game that will thrill long-time fans and introduce brand new ones to what Sonic is like at its very best. It is praised as a love-filled celebration that proves there is life in the 25-year-old original concept yet.

Read full review

100

PlayStation Country

PlayStation 4

Aug 21, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania is an absolute blast, potentially the best 2D Sonic title, highly recommended for fans and newcomers alike

Read full review

100

Gaming Age

PlayStation 4

Aug 14, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania is praised as one of the best Sonic the Hedgehog games since the Genesis days. It is recommended for Sonic fans and is considered a fantastic entry for the franchise.

Read full review

100

Vooks

Nintendo Switch

Sep 8, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania is the best Sonic game in decades, understanding what made the original Sonic games great and modernizing that essence for a new audience. Despite some minor flaws, the game is a follow-up worthy of standing with the best in the series.

Read full review

100

Nintendojo

Nintendo Switch

Aug 15, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania incorporates the old and the new, with great level design, heart-pounding music, and charming art direction, making it a return to form for Sonic the Hedgehog.

Read full review

Game Over Online

PlayStation 4

Aug 17, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania is highly praised as a remarkable game and the best Sonic title in over a decade, with a focus on its passion project nature, blend of old and new content, and potential impact on future Sonic games.

Vgames

Nintendo Switch

Aug 21, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Mania surpasses expectations, offering a seamless blend of nostalgia and innovation. A must-play for Sonic fans and platformer enthusiasts.