CRITIK

FIFA 18

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of FIFA 18
Item: FIFA 18
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2017

GenresThird Person Perspective, Simulation, Sports, Top-Down Perspective, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableSep 26, 2017

PlatformNintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One

DeveloperEA Vancouver

Overview

Nintendo Switch port of FIFA 18, which runs on a custom engine.

Elsewhere

7.1

Game analysis

Critik Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

50%

Mixed (50-79)

43%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Story of FIFA 18 are quite varied. Some critics, such as Sporting News and DualShockers, praise the story mode, known as The Journey, for its grounded and realistic approach, as well as its compelling narrative and likable characters. These critics highlight the enhancements from the previous installment and the inclusion of interactions with big names in the sport, which adds a sense of authenticity. Gaming Age also commends the game for its fantastic career/story mode that spans multiple continents and explores the protagonist's journey from an unknown teenager to a budding star, incorporating family drama and branching dialogue trees that impact the game's evolution. These positive opinions highlight the depth and complexity of the story in FIFA 18. However, not all critics share the same enthusiasm for the story mode. Critics like GameCritics and Critical Hit express their disappointment with The Journey. GameCritics goes as far as saying that it has already "jumped the shark," indicating a lack of interest or engagement with the story. Critical Hit criticizes the mode for being shallow and lacking consequence, despite the illusion of choice. These negative opinions suggest that the story mode may not live up to the expectations of some players, either due to its lack of depth or its failure to deliver meaningful consequences for the player's choices. Overall, the consensus among the critics is mixed. While some critics, such as Sporting News and GamingTrend, consider The Journey to be a standout narrative experience in a sports game, others, like Hardcore Gamer and TheSixthAxis, find it lacking in engagement or interest. The positive opinions highlight the grounded and realistic approach, compelling story, likable characters, and customization options that add a sense of individual personality. On the other hand, the negative opinions point out the shallowness, lack of consequence, and limited impact of the player's choices. It is clear that the story mode in FIFA 18 has its strengths and weaknesses, and players' enjoyment of it may vary depending on their preferences for narrative depth and engagement.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics have mixed opinions on FIFA 18's story mode, The Journey. Some praise its realistic approach, compelling narrative, and character development, while others criticize it for being shallow and lacking consequence. Positive reviews highlight the depth and complexity of the story, while negative ones point out a lack of engagement and impact. Overall, opinions are divided, with some considering it a standout narrative experience in a sports game, while others find it lacking in depth.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

83%

Mixed (50-79)

17%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The majority of the critics praised the gameplay of FIFA 18, with many highlighting its improvements and refinements. Game Informer commends the strong gameplay, mentioning the presence of jostling and off-the-ball support from AI teammates. GamePro Germany specifically mentions the pleasing passing mechanics and the game's performance on the Nintendo Switch in handheld mode. Metro GameCentral also emphasizes the smooth 60fps frame rate, which enhances the overall gameplay experience. Forbes praises the smoother and more responsive passes, improved running animations, and better AI defenders. PlayStation LifeStyle describes the gameplay as great, with tight through passes and satisfying moments that keep players engaged. However, there were some negative aspects mentioned by a few critics. IGN criticizes the sluggish controls and unresponsive dribbling, as well as the inept goalkeepers and the loss of momentum in long-range shots. GameGrin compares FIFA 18 to PES 2018 and states that PES is the better football game, mentioning that FIFA 18 lacks the tactical side of football. TheSixthAxis notes that defending in FIFA 18 takes time to get the hang of, indicating a learning curve for players. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the gameplay in FIFA 18 is very good. The majority of the reviewers praised the improvements and refinements, such as smoother passes, improved animations, and better AI defenders. The positive feedback from critics like Game Informer, GamePro Germany, Metro GameCentral, Forbes, and PlayStation LifeStyle supports the notion that FIFA 18 offers a satisfying and engaging gameplay experience. While there were some criticisms regarding sluggish controls, unresponsive dribbling, and defending learning curve, these negative aspects were outweighed by the positive feedback from the majority of critics.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics lauded FIFA 18's gameplay improvements like smoother passes and better AI defenders, with highlights on features like jostling and 60fps frame rate. Some critics noted issues like sluggish controls and defending learning curve, but overall, the consensus is that FIFA 18 delivers a satisfying gameplay experience.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

57%

Mixed (50-79)

43%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The majority of the critics praised the graphics and visual design of FIFA 18, considering it to be very good. Several critics, such as GameCrate and Cheat Code Central, specifically highlighted the stunning visuals and upgraded player models. The game was commended for its realistic and detailed visuals, with improved player likenesses and facial animations, as mentioned by critics like Hardcore Gamer and NZGamer. The use of the Frostbite engine was also appreciated, with Push Square mentioning impressive lighting and vibrant colors, and TheSixthAxis noting well-presented major leagues and regional overlays. The visuals were described as a technical beauty by GamingTrend and were said to enhance the excitement of the sport by Sporting News, with scenes and news clips adding tension and realism to transfer negotiations in the career mode. However, there were some criticisms regarding the graphics and visual design of FIFA 18. GamePro Germany, Pocket Gamer UK, and DualShockers mentioned that the Nintendo Switch version had inferior graphics compared to the PS4 and Xbox One versions, with missing smooth animations and less polished visuals. Forbes also noted that while the player models were rendered nicely, there was room for improvement in terms of player faces and hair realism. DualShockers further criticized the player models and animations for being generic and lacking emotion, while Gameplanet mentioned occasional awkward animations and repeated commentary lines. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that FIFA 18 has impressive graphics and visual design. The game was praised for its realistic visuals, improved player models, and authentic broadcast presentation overlays. The majority of the critics found the graphics to be stunning, with well-represented stadiums, slick menus, and vibrant colors. The use of the Frostbite engine was seen as a positive aspect, contributing to a visually appealing and realistic game. While there were some criticisms regarding specific versions of the game and minor issues with animations and player differentiation, the overall sentiment is that FIFA 18 delivers a visually satisfying experience.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics mostly loved FIFA 18's graphics, praising its stunning visuals, upgraded player models, and realistic details. The Frostbite engine impressed with impressive lighting and vibrant colors. Some critics noted flaws like inferior graphics on the Nintendo Switch version and generic player animations. Overall, FIFA 18 was praised for its impressive visuals, authentic presentation, and realistic feel, despite some minor criticisms.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

45%

Mixed (50-79)

45%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple videogame reviewers regarding the Sound Design and Music of FIFA 18, it is evident that there are both positive and negative aspects highlighted by the critics. The positive aspects mentioned by the reviewers include the impressive commentary and sound design, which contribute to the overall immersion and atmosphere of the game. GameSpot, DualShockers, and TheSixthAxis specifically mention the positive impact of the commentary on the gameplay experience, with GameSpot stating that the commentary is impressive and DualShockers highlighting its accuracy and immersion. The diverse soundtrack is also mentioned as a positive feature by NZGamer, adding to the overall positive sentiment towards the sound design and music of FIFA 18. However, there are also negative aspects highlighted by some of the critics. The voice-acting performances, particularly those of real-life players like Cristiano Ronaldo, are criticized by Guardian and VideoGamer. Guardian specifically mentions that Ronaldo's parts are excruciating, indicating a lack of quality in the voice acting. Push Square criticizes the commentary for being repetitive and of poor quality, which contrasts with the positive comments made by other reviewers regarding the commentary. Hardcore Gamer also points out that while the soundtrack is solid, it lacks well-known artists or songs, which may be seen as a drawback for some players. Overall, the consensus among the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of FIFA 18 leans towards the positive side. The impressive commentary, accurate overview of the game, and good sound design are praised by multiple reviewers such as GameSpot, DualShockers, and TheSixthAxis. The diverse soundtrack and overall polished presentation are also mentioned as positive features by NZGamer and PlayStation LifeStyle. However, there are some negative aspects highlighted by certain critics, such as the poor quality of voice acting and repetitive commentary. Despite these criticisms, the overall sentiment towards the sound design and music of FIFA 18 remains positive, with the positive aspects outweighing the negatives according to the majority of the reviewers.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics have mixed opinions on FIFA 18's Sound Design and Music. Positive feedback includes impressive commentary and sound design, enhancing gameplay immersion. However, some critics criticize voice acting, repetitive commentary, and lack of well-known songs in the soundtrack. Overall, most reviewers lean towards the positive side, praising the commentary and sound design while acknowledging some drawbacks.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

25%

Mixed (50-79)

75%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The opinions of the critics regarding the voice acting in FIFA 18 are varied, with some praising it and others expressing mixed feelings. DualShockers and Hardcore Gamer both have positive opinions, with DualShockers stating that the voice acting in The Journey: Hunter Returns is fantastic, and Hardcore Gamer mentioning that the voice acting in FIFA 18's single-player mode is well-performed, particularly by the lead actor. These positive opinions highlight the strong performances by the voice actors, which contribute to an immersive and engaging experience for players. On the other hand, there are critics who express some reservations about the voice acting in FIFA 18. PC Gamer notes that the real footballers used in the story have wooden acting, suggesting that their performances may lack depth and emotion. This criticism implies that the voice acting from the actual footballers may not meet the same level of quality as that of professional voice actors. Gaming Age also mentions that while the appearances of Cristiano Ronaldo, Rio Ferdinand, and James Harden add to the overall experience of the game, their voice acting skills may not be top-notch. This suggests that the celebrity presence in the game may not always translate to exceptional voice performances. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the voice acting in FIFA 18 is a mix of positive and negative elements. While there are strong performances by the lead actor and fictional characters like Kim, as noted by Hardcore Gamer, there are also instances where the voice acting from real footballers may fall short, as mentioned by PC Gamer. The presence of famous players, such as Cristiano Ronaldo, Rio Ferdinand, and James Harden, adds to the overall experience of the game, according to Gaming Age. However, it is important to note that the opinions of the critics are subjective, and individual players may have different experiences and perceptions of the voice acting in FIFA 18.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics have mixed feelings about the voice acting in FIFA 18. Some praise the performances for adding depth and immersion, while others criticize real footballers for wooden acting. While some highlight strong lead actor performances, others find celebrity voices lacking. Overall, opinions vary on whether the voice acting enhances or detracts from the game experience.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

55%

Mixed (50-79)

36%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of technical performance on the Nintendo Switch, there are mixed opinions among the critics. GamePro Germany and Pocket Gamer UK both highlight the smooth gameplay and lack of long loading times on the Switch version of FIFA 18. However, Game Informer notes that the Switch version lacks refinement in player movements, while IGN points out several missing features and hardware limitations that affect multiplayer, such as the inability to play online matches against friends. Switch Player also mentions encountering silly bugs and suggests that the game could benefit from patching. Overall, while the Switch version runs smoothly for some critics, there are noticeable limitations and bugs that detract from the technical performance. On the Xbox One, GameCrate mentions graphical glitches, such as disappearing character models and other classic FIFA glitches. Sporting News indicates that there may have been technical performance or stability issues in the game, as a patch was released to address issues with goalkeeping, although no specific details are provided. These criticisms suggest that the Xbox One version of FIFA 18 has some technical shortcomings that affect the overall gameplay experience. In contrast, the PlayStation 4 version of FIFA 18 seems to have a more positive reception in terms of technical performance. Hardcore Gamer reports no major glitches or framerate issues during their time with the game. The Digital Fix highlights that FIFA 18 works brilliantly well and has made improvements based on community feedback. The Sixth Axis also mentions solid servers and smooth gameplay, with no mention of technical issues. These positive reviews indicate that the PlayStation 4 version of FIFA 18 offers a more stable and enjoyable technical performance compared to the other gaming platforms. Overall, the critics' opinions on the technical performance of FIFA 18 vary depending on the gaming platform. While the Nintendo Switch version receives praise for its smooth gameplay and lack of long loading times, there are concerns about missing features and bugs. The Xbox One version is criticized for graphical glitches and potential technical performance issues, while the PlayStation 4 version is generally well-received with no major technical issues reported. It is important for players to consider these platform-specific factors when choosing which version of FIFA 18 to play.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics have mixed opinions on FIFA 18's technical performance across different gaming platforms. The Nintendo Switch version is praised for smooth gameplay but criticized for missing features and bugs. Xbox One faces issues with graphical glitches and stability, while PlayStation 4 receives positive feedback for solid performance and improvements based on player feedback. Consider platform-specific factors when choosing which version to play.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

56%

Mixed (50-79)

44%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

In analyzing the opinions of the videogame reviewers regarding the replay value of FIFA 18, it is evident that there are both positive and negative aspects highlighted by the critics. Starting with the positives, several reviewers mention the presence of various game modes that contribute to the replay value of FIFA 18. Game Informer notes that the career mode and Ultimate Team offer plenty of mileage to keep players busy. Metro GameCentral also mentions that most of the main game modes, including FIFA Ultimate Team, are present. The inclusion of FIFA Ultimate Team is particularly praised by critics such as GameCrate, GameGrin, and Worth Playing, who highlight its addictive nature and highly competitive ranking system. The addition of new single-player content in The Journey mode is also appreciated by Push Square. These positive aspects indicate that FIFA 18 provides a range of options and game modes that can engage players for extended periods. However, there are also negative aspects mentioned by some critics. GamePro Germany and Pocket Gamer UK highlight that FIFA 18 on the Nintendo Switch is missing features and modes compared to other platforms. GameSpot further emphasizes this by stating that the only offline options on the Switch version are Kick Off and Career Mode, which is similar to FIFA 16 and does not include the latest additions. The lack of online play with friends on the Switch version is also criticized by Switch Player. These negatives suggest that the replay value of FIFA 18 may be limited on the Nintendo Switch platform due to the absence of certain features and modes. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that FIFA 18 offers a significant amount of replay value. Critics such as GameCritics, Sporting News, and The Digital Fix highlight the various game modes and features available, including FIFA Ultimate Team, Career Mode, and The Journey, which contribute to the game's replayability. The positive reception of FIFA Ultimate Team by critics like DualShockers and TheSixthAxis further emphasizes its strong hold on players. While there are some criticisms regarding the lack of features on the Nintendo Switch version, the overall sentiment suggests that FIFA 18 provides ample content and options for both newcomers and passionate fans, making it a satisfying entry point for players of all levels of experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics praise FIFA 18 for its various engaging game modes like FIFA Ultimate Team and Career Mode, offering ample replay value. However, some reviewers criticize the Nintendo Switch version for lacking features present in other platforms, potentially limiting its replayability. Overall, FIFA 18 is seen as a satisfying game with options for all players, despite some platform-specific drawbacks.

Overall Verdict

CRITIK

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Critik Score

Positive (80-100)

71%

Mixed (50-79)

29%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

Overall, the majority of critics had a positive opinion of FIFA 18, considering it a very good game. The game was praised for its enjoyable gameplay, improvements in various aspects, and the value it offers to both newcomers and passionate fans of the series. Critics such as Sporting News and Gaming Age highlighted the fantastic career mode and solid gameplay experience, which made FIFA 18 stand out as a standout sports game. The game was also commended for its polished presentation, improved controls, and player differentiation, as mentioned by Cheat Code Central. Additionally, critics like Gameplanet and The Digital Fix regarded FIFA 18 as a more complete and system-selling experience, with subtle tweaks and additions that made it the best football game on the market. However, there were some negatives pointed out by the critics. One common criticism was the lack of features and modes, especially when compared to the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions. IGN mentioned that FIFA 18 on the Switch felt stripped back and lacked many appealing franchise features, while GameSpot highlighted the limited offline options and restrictions on FUT and online matchmaking with friends. Game Informer also mentioned that FIFA 18 on the Switch was hampered by Nintendo's insufficient online strategy. Some critics, like GameGrin, also noted that PES 2018 was considered the better football game by comparison. Overall, the consensus among the critics was that FIFA 18 was a positive step forward for the series, with improvements in gameplay, presentation, and overall experience. The game was recommended for both new and returning players, especially for those interested in the single-player content. Critics such as GamePro Germany and Switch Player acknowledged that FIFA 18 on the Switch was a better portable experience compared to previous Nintendo consoles, but it still fell short when compared to other versions. Despite some minor issues and the lack of certain features, FIFA 18 was generally regarded as a highly enjoyable and worthwhile game, particularly for fans of the franchise.

TL;DR

Critics largely praised FIFA 18 for its enjoyable gameplay, improvements, and value for both newcomers and series fans. The game stood out for its career mode and gameplay, with polished presentation and player differentiation. However, criticisms included a lack of features compared to other versions, limited offline options, and being overshadowed by PES 2018. Overall, FIFA 18 was seen as a positive step forward, recommended for players interested in single-player content, but fell short in some areas on the Nintendo Switch compared to other platforms.

CRITIK

Reviews

123 reviews found

100

Gaming Age

PlayStation 4

Sep 29, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

FIFA 18 delivers a fantastic career mode and a solid gameplay experience, making it a standout sports game. The reviewer's opinion on sports games is based on the quality of the career mode and how well it represents the sport, and FIFA 18 excels in both aspects.

Read full review

PlayStation LifeStyle

PlayStation 4

Sep 25, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

FIFA 18 is an incredible football game that has something to offer every gamer, with a compelling story and polished gameplay.

Forbes

PlayStation 4

Sep 20, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review gives FIFA 18 a score of 9 out of 10.

Cheat Code Central

PlayStation 4

Sep 21, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises FIFA 18 as a simple, yet highly impactful game that looks gorgeous and provides a new experience. It also mentions improvements in controls and player differentiation. No negative aspects are mentioned.

Read full review

The Digital Fix

PlayStation 4

Oct 20, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that FIFA 18 is a system seller and EA has hit it out of the park again.

GamesRadar+

PlayStation 4

Sep 25, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that FIFA 18 offers remarkable value and is a monster season for both big football games.

Read full review

Gameplanet

PlayStation 4

Sep 29, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

FIFA 18 is a more complete experience compared to previous iterations, with subtle tweaks and additions that make it the best football game on the market.

Hardcore Gamer

PlayStation 4

Sep 25, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

FIFA 18 is a consistently enjoyable game with improvements to gameplay and presentation, although some modes could have been better.

GameCrate

Xbox One

Oct 2, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is enjoyable and the only major issue is the visual glitches.

Worth Playing

PlayStation 4

Oct 30, 2017

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

FIFA 18 is a gorgeous-looking soccer game with tight gameplay and an interesting ranking system in the Ultimate Team mode. It is recommended for those looking for a soccer game.

Read full review