CRITIK

FIFA 15

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of FIFA 15
Item: FIFA 15
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2014

GenresThird Person Perspective, Simulation, Sports, Top-Down Perspective, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableSep 23, 2014

PlatformPC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4

DeveloperEA Sports

Overview

PC version of FIFA 15, running on the new Ignition Engine, but with the features from the PS3/Xbox 360 version.

Elsewhere

7.1

Game analysis

Critik Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

story and narrative

Description unavailable

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

72%

Mixed (50-79)

28%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the gameplay of FIFA 15 are varied, with many positive aspects highlighted. Critics like GRYOnline.pl and PC Games praise the improvements in gameplay mechanics, such as faster pace, more unpredictable ball behavior, and revamped tackling, which enhance the overall experience. COGconnected commends the tight gameplay, improved ball physics, and realistic goalkeeper movements, while Eurogamer Germany appreciates the enhanced player reactions, refined ball control, and challenging goalkeepers. These positive aspects contribute to a more engaging and immersive gameplay experience, with smoother animations, improved player control, and impactful team strategies being noted by various critics. On the negative side, some critics point out issues with the gameplay of FIFA 15. Hooked Gamers criticizes the defending controls, while PC Gamer mentions that matches are often played on the counterattack with computer-controlled players making ridiculous runs. Digital Spy highlights that defending can be a chore, and Metro GameCentral criticizes the lack of logic in gameplay changes. Additionally, Cheat Code Central finds FIFA 15 very similar to its predecessor, and Pure Xbox notes some issues with goalkeepers and defending. These criticisms indicate that while there are improvements in gameplay, there are still areas that could be refined or addressed to enhance the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that FIFA 15 offers a mix of positive and negative aspects in its gameplay. While there are notable improvements in player responsiveness, ball physics, and tactical depth, as mentioned by critics like Guardian and PlayStation Universe, there are also criticisms regarding defending controls, gameplay logic, and similarity to previous iterations. The game's faster pace, enhanced animations, and realistic player movements are generally well-received, but there are areas that could be further developed to provide a more balanced and refined gameplay experience. Critics like Game Informer and TheSixthAxis acknowledge the changes in tackling, goalkeeper intelligence, and AI improvements, indicating that FIFA 15 introduces significant alterations to the gameplay that impact the overall enjoyment and immersion for players.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics praise FIFA 15 for improved gameplay mechanics like faster pace and realistic player movements, but note issues with defending controls and gameplay logic. While the game offers engaging player responsiveness and enhanced animations, there are areas that could be refined for a more balanced experience.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

65%

Mixed (50-79)

35%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of FIFA 15, it is evident that the majority of critics had positive feedback on the game's visuals. Several reviewers, such as COGconnected and The Digital Fix, praised the realistic player movements, enhanced atmosphere, and detailed player likenesses that contributed to an immersive experience. The addition of new graphical elements like corner flag physics, goal frames that shake, and animated LED ad boards, as highlighted by COGconnected, further enhanced the overall visual appeal. The attention to detail in recreating Premier League stadiums, as noted by Official Xbox Magazine UK and Pure Xbox, also received commendation for capturing the essence of a live football broadcast. On the flip side, some critics pointed out specific areas where FIFA 15 fell short in terms of graphics and visual design. Hooked Gamers highlighted that while the visual spectacle was praised, there were occasional glitches in player animations that detracted from the realism. Critical Hit expressed disappointment in the graphics being similar to FIFA 14, which was seen as a negative point by the reviewer. Gamer.nl also mentioned inconsistent player animations and outdated character models that hindered the visual presentation of the game. Overall, the consensus among critics leans heavily towards the positive side, with the majority acknowledging the impressive graphics and visual design of FIFA 15. The game's realistic player models, immersive stadium atmosphere, and attention to detail in player animations were widely appreciated, as seen in reviews from Eurogamer Germany, Guardian, and Push Square. Despite some minor issues such as occasional glitches and similarities to previous iterations, the overall sentiment reflects a strong appreciation for the graphical improvements in FIFA 15. The game successfully delivered a visually stunning and authentic football experience, garnering praise for its next-gen visuals and attention to detail that elevated the overall presentation to a broadcast-level standard, as highlighted by games(TM) and PlayStation Universe.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics mostly praised FIFA 15's impressive graphics, realistic player movements, and detailed stadiums, though some noted occasional glitches and similarities to FIFA 14. Overall, the game delivered a visually stunning football experience with next-gen visuals and attention to detail that elevated the presentation to a broadcast-level standard.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

43%

Mixed (50-79)

57%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of FIFA 15 received generally positive feedback from critics. Many reviewers praised the immersive sound design, with specific mentions of authentic crowd chants, cheers, and reactions adding to the overall atmosphere of the game. Critics like COGconnected and Guardian highlighted the realistic stadium ambiance and custom behaviors for crowds, enhancing the gameplay experience. Additionally, the inclusion of diverse music selections, as noted by LevelUp and Impulsegamer, was also appreciated, with mentions of iconic tracks and Latin American Spanish commentary adding passion to the game. On the downside, some critics pointed out issues with repetitive commentary, such as Xbox Achievements mentioning that the commentary can become annoying with repeated phrases. Additionally, there were mixed opinions on the new player emotion feature, with Game Informer and Eurogamer noting that it was not remarkable. Some critics, like GRYOnline.pl, hinted at potential sound design issues that were not explicitly discussed in their reviews, suggesting that there may have been minor flaws in this aspect of the game. Overall, the consensus among critics is that FIFA 15 excelled in creating an immersive audio experience through authentic crowd reactions, improved commentary, and a diverse soundtrack. Critics like Hardcore Gamer and God is a Geek praised the realistic sound effects and passionate crowd reactions, enhancing the overall gameplay experience. While there were some criticisms regarding repetitive commentary and the new player emotion feature, the majority of reviewers appreciated the efforts made to bridge the gap between the virtual soccer world and reality. The focus on enhancing the broadcast-style presentation, as noted by Joystiq, and the incorporation of licensed stadium sounds and player emotions, as highlighted by Eurogamer, contributed to the game's immersive atmosphere.

TL;DR

music and sound design

FIFA 15's sound design and music were praised for their immersive experience, featuring authentic crowd reactions and diverse music choices. Critics appreciated the realistic stadium ambiance but had mixed opinions on repetitive commentary and the new player emotion feature. Overall, reviewers lauded the game for bridging the virtual soccer world with reality, despite some minor flaws noted by a few critics.

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

31%

Mixed (50-79)

63%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of technical performance on PC, the general consensus among critics is positive. PC Gamer notes that the game runs well on an upper mid-range PC rig, indicating smooth gameplay and performance. PC Games, despite initial technical issues, highlights that a Day-1 Patch resolved these issues, showcasing a commitment to addressing and improving technical aspects for PC players. These positive reviews suggest that FIFA 15 offers a solid technical experience on the PC platform. On the other hand, when it comes to Xbox One, there are mixed opinions regarding technical performance. While CalmDownTom praises the game as solid out of the box without the need for post-release patches, Pure Xbox points out issues with goalkeepers making unrealistic mistakes that can negatively impact gameplay. Critical Hit mentions that despite technical magnificence, the game struggles to keep up with rule changes, indicating a disconnect between technical prowess and gameplay adjustments. These varying opinions on Xbox One highlight the presence of both positive and negative technical aspects in FIFA 15 on this platform. Moving on to the PlayStation 4, critics also have diverse views on the technical performance of FIFA 15. Gamer.nl and Softpedia commend the improved online performance and smooth gameplay on next-gen consoles, indicating technical stability and advancements in graphics and gameplay. However, Gamestyle and Push Square report server issues, lag, and disconnect problems, detracting from the overall technical experience. The SixthAxis notes minor frustrations with delays and unresponsive buttons, while games(TM) mentions physics-related problems. This mix of positive and negative feedback on the PS4 platform suggests a more nuanced technical performance in FIFA 15 for PlayStation users. Overall, while FIFA 15 receives praise for technical improvements and smooth performance on platforms like PC, Xbox One, and PS4 from critics like Eurogamer Germany and Softpedia, there are also concerns raised by reviewers such as Gamestyle and Push Square regarding server issues, lag, and gameplay problems. The consensus leans towards acknowledging the technical advancements in FIFA 15 compared to previous iterations, but the presence of technical issues like glitches, lag, and AI problems cannot be ignored. The game seems to offer a mixed technical experience across different platforms, with room for improvement in addressing technical issues to enhance overall gameplay satisfaction for players.

TL;DR

technical performance

FIFA 15 earns positive reviews for technical performance on PC, with smooth gameplay and a commitment to fixing issues. Xbox One reviews vary, noting solid performance but goalie mistakes impacting play. PlayStation 4 feedback is mixed, with praise for online play but criticism for server problems and delays. While the game shows technical improvements, issues like glitches and lag persist, indicating room for enhancement across platforms.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

41%

Mixed (50-79)

59%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of various critics regarding the replay value of FIFA 15 highlight several positive aspects. Critics like GRYOnline.pl and The Digital Fix praise the enhancements in the Ultimate Team mode, such as the introduction of loan players and concept squads, which provide new ways for players to engage with the game and experiment with their line-ups. Game Informer and Guardian also commend the diverse gameplay experiences offered by various game modes like career mode, Be a Pro seasons, and skill games, which contribute to the game's replayability. Additionally, Eurogamer Germany mentions new features like tournament mode, Ultimate Team improvements, and the Match Day Live hub, adding depth to the gameplay experience and increasing replay value. On the flip side, some critics point out certain drawbacks that may impact the replayability of FIFA 15. PC Games notes minor flaws like the lack of significant changes from the previous version and limited improvements in certain game modes, which could potentially lead to a feeling of stagnation for returning players. Pure Xbox highlights goalkeeper issues that may frustrate players and affect the overall replayability of the game. Furthermore, critics like God is a Geek express disappointment in the neglect of the Career Mode, with only a few cosmetic changes and lacking significant updates, which could deter players looking for fresh content and experiences. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards FIFA 15 offering solid replay value due to its engaging gameplay mechanics, diverse game modes, and enhancements in the Ultimate Team mode. Critics like USgamer highly praise the game for its peerless online play, high-quality career modes, and enjoyable on-field gameplay, making it worth investing a significant amount of playtime. While there are some criticisms regarding minor flaws, lack of significant updates in certain modes, and issues like goalkeeper mechanics, the general sentiment is that FIFA 15 succeeds in providing an immersive and addictive experience for both avid fans and newcomers alike. The game's mix of familiar modes and new features like loan players and concept squads in Ultimate Team mode contribute to its overall replayability, ensuring that players can find enjoyment and longevity in their FIFA 15 experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics praise FIFA 15 for its enhanced Ultimate Team mode, diverse gameplay experiences, and new features like loan players and concept squads, boosting replay value. However, some point out drawbacks such as lack of significant changes from previous versions, goalkeeper issues, and neglect of Career Mode. Overall, FIFA 15 offers solid replay value with engaging mechanics and modes, despite minor flaws, making it a worthwhile investment for both fans and newcomers.

Overall Verdict

CRITIK

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Critik Score

Positive (80-100)

83%

Mixed (50-79)

17%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

Overall, FIFA 15 received a mix of positive and negative feedback from critics. The game was widely praised for its improvements in gameplay, graphics, and presentation. Critics such as PC Games and Pure Xbox highlighted the engaging and realistic football experience offered by FIFA 15, appealing to both casual players and hardcore fans. The tactical gameplay, improved AI, and realistic animations were also commended. Additionally, Eurogamer Germany and Game Informer noted significant enhancements in gameplay and technical aspects, making FIFA 15 a compelling choice for football enthusiasts. The game's immersive experience, small refinements, and atmospheric changes were lauded by Digital Chumps and Polygon, showcasing the developers' efforts to maintain the series' strong foundation while introducing subtle improvements. On the downside, some critics pointed out issues with FIFA 15 that detracted from the overall experience. Hooked Gamers criticized the defending controls, while Metro GameCentral highlighted the confusion between changes and improvements, particularly in the goalkeeping mechanics. Critical Hit and X-ONE Magazine UK expressed disappointment in the lack of innovation and risks taken by the developers, suggesting that the game may be lagging behind in terms of evolution. Cheat Code Central and PlayStation Universe echoed similar sentiments, mentioning the lack of significant advancements and questioning the value of the graphical improvements compared to previous iterations. Despite the mixed feedback, the overall consensus among critics leans towards FIFA 15 being a solid entry in the series that delivers an enjoyable football simulation experience. While some reviewers like Guardian and Game Informer acknowledged the incremental improvements and enhancements over previous installments, others like TheSixthAxis and USgamer praised the evolutionary leap in gameplay and the game's overall realism. The variety of positive alterations, excellent career modes, and the immersive football experience were highlighted as key strengths of FIFA 15 by critics such as Push Square and games(TM). Ultimately, while FIFA 15 may not have been revolutionary, it managed to maintain its status as one of the best sports simulations available, offering a satisfying experience for both dedicated fans and newcomers to the franchise.

TL;DR

FIFA 15 received mixed feedback from critics, with praise for its gameplay, graphics, and presentation. Critics highlighted the realistic football experience, improved AI, and immersive atmosphere. However, some critics noted issues with defending controls and lack of innovation, suggesting the game may be lagging behind. Overall, FIFA 15 is seen as a solid entry in the series, offering an enjoyable football simulation experience with incremental improvements and solid gameplay.

CRITIK

Reviews

114 reviews found

100

Guardian

Xbox One

Sep 23, 2014