Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One cover image

Links

CRITIK

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Item: Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2021

GenresAdventure, Indie, Action, Third Person Perspective, Open World, Simulation, Puzzle and Logic, Mystery, Single Player, First Person Perspective

AvailableNov 16, 2021

PlatformPC, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4

DeveloperFrogwares

Overview

In this story-driven detective thriller, a young Sherlock Holmes struggles to prove himself as he navigates an exotic, dangerous island in the Mediterranean to investigate the mystery of his mother’s death. As Sherlock, your legacy is written by the decisions you make in this open world. Deception, violence, and deduction are just a few resources in your arsenal—your mysterious companion and sounding board, Jon, is another. Whether you choose brute force to solve problems or stay one step ahead of your enemies by using your wits to spot vulnerabilities, you decide what each situation demands as you hone your investigative skills. It’s time to confront your past so you can become the legend you’re destined to be.

Elsewhere

7.7

Game analysis

Critik Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

89%

Mixed (50-79)

11%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One are generally positive. Many critics praise the game's story, highlighting its focus on Sherlock Holmes' origins and his journey to uncover the truth about his mother's death. Critics like COGconnected and GameSpew appreciate the emotional transition of Holmes and the exploration of his childhood home. The story is described as authentic, well-written, and captivating by critics like WellPlayed and Softpedia. The narrative is also commended for its darker tone, exploration of mental health and trauma, and the poignant finale by critics like GameGrin and Guardian. The setting of the fictional Mediterranean island of Cordona is praised for its immersive atmosphere and interesting cast of characters by critics like Impulsegamer and GAMES.CH. However, there are some critics who express more negative opinions about the story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Gaming Age mentions that the story is forgettable and lacks innovation compared to previous Sherlock Holmes games. Pure Xbox criticizes the presentation of the story, noting unclear directions and instances of roadblocks. Movies Games and Tech mentions that the game becomes filled with odd encounters and weird characters, which may detract from the overall storytelling experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is engaging and enjoyable. It is praised for its exploration of Sherlock Holmes' origins, the portrayal of a younger Holmes, and the themes of mental health and trauma. The narrative is described as well-structured, captivating, and offering a unique insight into Sherlock's thoughts and emotions. The game's setting and atmosphere also contribute to the positive reception of the story. While there are some criticisms regarding forgettable elements, unclear directions, and odd encounters, the overall sentiment is that the story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is a solid and captivating experience.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics generally praise the engaging and well-written story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, focusing on Holmes' origins and emotional journey. They appreciate the exploration of mental health and trauma, the darker tone, and the immersive setting of Cordona. Some critics find the story forgettable and criticize unclear directions, but overall, the consensus is that it offers a captivating and unique insight into Sherlock's character.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

30%

Mixed (50-79)

70%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the gameplay of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One are generally positive. Many critics highlight the engaging and immersive gameplay mechanics that involve investigating crime scenes, gathering evidence, and making deductions. Critics like GameSpew, GamesRadar++, and Worth Playing appreciate the game's focus on detective work and the satisfaction of piecing together clues to solve mysteries. The inclusion of new elements, such as side-cases and various investigative tasks, is also praised by Video Chums. The core mechanics of investigation, including Holmes' ability to observe and learn intricate details, are well-implemented, according to CGMagazine. The open-world aspect of the game, mentioned by GameStar and Pure Xbox, adds a sense of freedom and exploration to the gameplay experience. However, there are also some negative opinions regarding the gameplay of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. COGconnected criticizes the investigation mechanics for being opaque, and Softpedia mentions that the game requires attention and brain cells. Screen Rant criticizes the frustrating puzzles and the combat system, which contradicts the core concept of Sherlock Holmes. Gaming Nexus mentions feeling overwhelmed with side quests and experiencing moments of being stuck, which detracted from the overall enjoyment. The combat sequences are considered awful by WellPlayed and not well-implemented by GameGrin and Gaming Nexus. The lack of hand-holding and specific order of completing tasks can be frustrating, as mentioned by Movies Games and Tech and Pure Xbox. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One offers a satisfying and immersive gameplay experience. The game successfully captures the essence of being a detective, with engaging mechanics that involve investigating crime scenes, gathering evidence, and making deductions. The inclusion of new elements, such as side-cases and various investigative tasks, adds depth and variety to the gameplay. The open-world aspect allows for exploration and adds to the sense of immersion. However, there are some areas of improvement, such as the opaque investigation mechanics, frustrating puzzles, and underwhelming combat system. Despite these flaws, the gameplay of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is generally well-received by critics, offering an enjoyable and challenging experience for fans of the detective genre.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics praise Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One for its engaging detective gameplay, immersive mechanics, and focus on solving mysteries through investigation. The game's new elements like side-cases and investigative tasks are well-received, adding depth to the experience. However, some criticize the opaque investigation mechanics, frustrating puzzles, and lackluster combat system. Overall, while the game captures the essence of being a detective and offers a satisfying gameplay experience, there are areas that could be improved for a more seamless and enjoyable experience.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

36%

Mixed (50-79)

56%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One are mixed. Several critics praised the game's visuals, particularly the detailed open world and the beautiful setting of the fictional Mediterranean island of Cordona. Critics such as GameSpew, God is a Geek, and Softpedia appreciated the impressive architecture and the attention to authentic details in the game's environment. The visuals were also commended for their sharp details on clothing and cleaner character faces, as mentioned by Worth Playing. The game's world-building, architecture, and art direction were considered significant accomplishments by COGconnected. The graphics were described as gorgeous and the attention to detail was praised by GameGrin and Impulsegamer. However, there were also negative opinions regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Some critics, such as Gaming Age and Worth Playing, mentioned issues with character design, facial animations, and lip-syncing, which they felt were outdated and broke the mood and immersion of the game. PlayStation LifeStyle and Screen Rant criticized the open-world setting of Cordona for feeling empty in places, having repeated NPC models, and struggling with frame rate issues, making the gameplay feel choppy. Pure Xbox mentioned technical issues like texture pop-in, character glitches, and a poor framerate, which affected the overall visual experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One has visually appealing aspects, such as the beautiful setting, impressive architecture, and attention to detail. However, there are also significant drawbacks, including outdated character design and facial animations, repetitive NPC models, technical issues, and performance problems. While some critics, like GameGrin and Impulsegamer, found the graphics to be impressive and praised the attention to detail, others, such as PlayStation LifeStyle and Pure Xbox, expressed disappointment with the technical issues and lack of polish. It is evident that the game's Graphics and Visual Design received a mixed reception from the critics, with both positive and negative aspects being highlighted.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics have mixed opinions on the Graphics and Visual Design of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Some praise the detailed open world and gorgeous setting of Cordona, while others criticize issues with character design, facial animations, and technical problems like texture pop-in and framerate issues. Overall, the game's visuals have both impressive aspects and significant drawbacks, leading to a varied reception among critics.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

64%

Mixed (50-79)

36%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

In analyzing the opinions of the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, it is evident that there are several positive aspects highlighted by the reviewers. COGconnected commends the musical score and overall sound design, considering them excellent. Softpedia also praises the well-crafted soundtrack for enhancing the atmosphere. Video Chums appreciates the immersive experience created by the constant murmurs and background sounds of the island's inhabitants, as well as the well-done voice acting, particularly for the younger version of Sherlock. WellPlayed highlights the high-quality voice acting and writing, particularly in the relationship between Sherlock and Jon, which feels authentic and invests the player in their relationship. GameWatcher acknowledges that the music fits the atmosphere of the game, and Guardian praises the voice acting. TheXboxHub emphasizes the exciting and dynamic soundtrack, along with great audio effects in detective mode. Xbox Achievements states that the voice acting is rock solid and the music is lovely. However, there are also some negative aspects mentioned by the critics. COGconnected notes that some investigations can become repetitive. Worth Playing criticizes the voice-overs, stating that they range from mediocre to bad, with minor personalities sounding like random people reading lines without awareness of the situation. CGMagazine mentions that some dialogue can become repetitive when talking to certain classes of citizens. Movies Games and Tech raises concerns about the inclusion of offensive comments in the dialogue. Guardian finds the imaginary friend character, Jon, annoying and lacking helpful hints. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the Sound Design and Music of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One are generally well-received. The positive aspects highlighted include the excellent musical score and overall sound design, the well-crafted soundtrack that enhances the atmosphere, and the high-quality voice acting that brings authenticity to the characters and their relationships. However, there are some criticisms regarding repetitive investigations, mediocre to bad voice-overs, repetitive dialogue in certain situations, offensive comments in the dialogue, and an annoying imaginary friend character. Despite these negatives, the overall sentiment leans towards appreciation for the sound design and music in the game.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics praise the sound design and music of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One for its excellent score, immersive atmosphere, and high-quality voice acting. However, some criticize repetitive investigations, mediocre voice-overs, and annoying characters. Overall, the consensus is positive, with the majority appreciating the game's sound design and music.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

70%

Mixed (50-79)

20%

Negative (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The overall sentiment regarding the voice acting in Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is mixed, with some critics praising it while others have reservations. Several critics, such as Video Chums and CGMagazine, commend the voice acting, describing it as well-done and enjoyable. Video Chums specifically highlights the younger version of Sherlock, stating that the voice acting for this character is particularly well done. CGMagazine adds that the voice acting never feels repetitive or unnatural, further emphasizing its quality. Additionally, GameGrin gives special recognition to Alex Jordan for his portrayal of young Sherlock Holmes, praising the depth of emotion he brings to the character. However, there are also critics who express more negative opinions about the voice acting in the game. Worth Playing and TheXboxHub both mention that the voice acting ranges from mediocre to bad, with minor characters suffering more than main ones. Worth Playing even goes as far as to say that the voice acting significantly disrupts the experience at times. TheXboxHub specifically points out that some extras come across as a bit 'Dick Van Dyke in Mary Poppins', suggesting that their performances may not be up to par. Overall, the consensus among the critics is somewhat divided. While some, like WellPlayed and Guardian, praise the high quality and authenticity of the voice acting, others, such as Worth Playing and TheXboxHub, have reservations about certain aspects. It is worth noting that the majority of critics seem to appreciate the voice acting, with only a few expressing more negative opinions. This suggests that, despite some shortcomings, the voice acting in Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One generally leaves a positive impression on reviewers.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics have mixed feelings about the voice acting in Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Some praise it for being well-done and enjoyable, especially for the character of young Sherlock. Others criticize it as ranging from mediocre to bad, with minor characters suffering the most. While opinions vary, most reviewers appreciate the voice acting, with only a few expressing negative views. Overall, the voice acting makes a positive impression on reviewers despite some shortcomings.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

85%

Negative (0-49)

15%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of the technical performance on the PS5, the opinions of the critics are mixed. GameSpew acknowledges some rough edges such as duff textures and lip syncing issues, but they don't significantly impact the gameplay experience. Worth Playing and PlayStation LifeStyle both mention frequent frame rate drops and muddy textures, making the game's performance on PS5 rough. Screen Rant adds that there are performance issues such as stuttering, slowdown, and assets disappearing & reappearing. However, Video Chums only mentions occasional issues with progression and a suggestion for a HUD option. Despite these technical issues, WellPlayed mentions that Frogwares plans to fix the performance problems with a patch. On the PC platform, the technical performance seems to be relatively better. PC Invasion states that the game runs at a stable 60 fps at 4K resolution on high settings, but this is based on a high-end system. Impulsegamer mentions that there were few and far between framerate stutters and cuts. Guardian, on the other hand, simply mentions that the game has some technical issues without going into specific details. GameWatcher also notes minor frame rate hiccups and occasional drops, but considers them tolerable overall. Moving on to the Xbox Series X, the critics' opinions are more negative. Pure Xbox mentions technical issues such as texture pop-in, character glitches, and a poor framerate. Xbox Achievements, however, states that the game has minor flaws like clipping and flickering textures, but overall remains stable. NME points out that the controls are described as clunky and not fluid, especially when playing on a console, but it is not considered a dealbreaker. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One has technical performance issues across all gaming platforms. The PS5 version seems to suffer the most, with frequent frame rate drops, muddy textures, and various performance issues. The PC version generally performs better, with stable frame rates and occasional minor hiccups. The Xbox Series X version also has its fair share of technical problems, including poor frame rates and control issues. Despite these technical issues, some critics mention that the game's performance is tolerable or can be improved with future patches.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics have mixed opinions on the technical performance of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. PS5 faces frequent frame rate drops and muddy textures, while PC runs smoothly on high-end systems. Xbox Series X has more negative feedback with texture pop-in and control issues. Overall, technical issues plague all platforms, but patches may improve the gameplay experience.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

31%

Mixed (50-79)

63%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One are generally positive. Many critics mention the presence of side content and additional activities that contribute to the game's replayability. GamesRadar++ states that the game offers replay value for players who enjoy the investigative gameplay and roleplaying as Sherlock Holmes. God is a Geek mentions that while the main story can be completed in under 8 hours, there is additional side content to explore. PlayStation LifeStyle highlights the open-world setting with various activities to investigate, which adds to the game's replay value. Video Chums also emphasizes the presence of numerous detailed side-stories, hidden items, and collectibles that enhance the replayability of the game. WellPlayed mentions the inclusion of side cases to be solved, providing additional content and replay value. CGMagazine also supports the notion of numerous side quests adding to the replay value of the game. GameGrin suggests that the game offers numerous side quests that further develop the understanding of the characters, recommending players to give the game the time and love it deserves to fully appreciate it. MondoXbox mentions the substantial amount of content in the game, with optional side quests and a 100% completion goal, indicating a high replay value. However, there are some critics who express concerns about the replayability of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Worth Playing mentions that while the game offers multiple endings and allows players to reach their own conclusions, the open world lacks content and becomes repetitive after a few hours. PC Invasion criticizes the game for lacking replayability, stating that it becomes too linear and lacks long-term consequences or branching paths. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One offers a decent amount of replay value. The presence of side content, side quests, additional cases, and multiple endings contribute to the game's replayability. Positive reviews from critics like GamesRadar++, God is a Geek, PlayStation LifeStyle, and Video Chums highlight the enjoyable investigative gameplay and the presence of various activities to explore. However, critics like Worth Playing and PC Invasion express concerns about the lack of content in the open world and the linear nature of the game. Despite these criticisms, the majority of critics acknowledge the game's replay value and recommend it to players who enjoy the Sherlock Holmes experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics praise Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One for its replay value, citing side content, multiple endings, and additional activities that enhance the game's lasting appeal. Positive reviews emphasize the investigative gameplay and variety of side quests, while some critics express concerns about repetitive open-world content and linear progression. Overall, the consensus is that the game offers decent replayability, recommended for fans of Sherlock Holmes looking for an engaging experience.

Overall Verdict

CRITIK

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Critik Score

Positive (80-100)

49%

Mixed (50-79)

50%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple reviewers regarding the Overall Verdict of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, it is evident that the game has received a mix of positive and negative feedback. Starting with the positives, many critics praised the game's ambition and fresh take on the Sherlock Holmes franchise. COGconnected commends the game for its scope and suggests that it may set a new high bar for the franchise. GameSpew considers it the developer's best game yet, highlighting its engaging and immersive gameplay that makes players feel like detectives. God is a Geek describes the game as ambitious with a satisfying overall experience, while CGMagazine goes as far as calling it their favorite game of the year, praising its charm, elegance, and respect for Doyle's original character. These positive reviews indicate that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One successfully delivers on its promise of a fresh and enjoyable detective experience. However, alongside the positive feedback, there are also criticisms raised by several reviewers. One common complaint is the presence of technical issues and performance problems. Screen Rant mentions performance issues and frustrating puzzles, while Worth Playing highlights technical issues and disruptive voice acting. PC Invasion points out shortcomings in graphics and replayability, and The Guardian mentions technical issues and lack of polish. These criticisms suggest that the game could have benefited from further optimization and refinement in certain areas. Despite the mixed feedback, the overall consensus among the critics leans towards a positive reception of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. Many reviewers appreciate the game's well-crafted narrative, engaging gameplay mechanics, and immersive detective experience. PlayStation LifeStyle recommends the game for fans of detective games, emphasizing the blast it is to play with its investigation mechanics and variety of cases. NME describes it as an intriguing and satisfying game for fans of solid mystery solving, while Xbox Achievements considers it the most assured video game take on the literary sleuth to date. The positive aspects of the game, such as the engaging main cases, insights into Sherlock's formative years, and the solid experience it provides, are acknowledged by multiple critics. However, it is important to note that there are criticisms raised regarding technical issues, pacing, and certain design choices, which may impact the overall enjoyment for some players. Overall, Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One appears to be a game that successfully captures the essence of the detective genre and offers an enjoyable experience for fans of Sherlock Holmes and investigative adventures. While there are areas that could have been improved, such as technical performance and certain gameplay mechanics, the game's ambition, well-crafted narrative, and immersive gameplay mechanics have garnered positive feedback from many critics. It is worth noting that individual preferences may vary, and players who appreciate the era-specific imagery, challenging mysteries, and a fresh take on the character are likely to find the game thoroughly enjoyable.

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One receives a mix of positive and negative feedback from reviewers. Critics praise its ambition, fresh take on the franchise, and engaging gameplay, but raise concerns about technical issues and performance problems. Overall, the game is well-received for its narrative, gameplay mechanics, and immersive experience, making it a solid choice for fans of detective games despite some flaws like technical issues and pacing.

CRITIK

Reviews

115 reviews found

100

XBLA Fans

Xbox Series X

Feb 23, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A highly recommended game with a lot of content and a lower price point compared to AAA titles.

100

GameGrin

Nov 16, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review considers Sherlock Holmes Chapter One as one of the reviewer's favorite games of all time, praising its graphics, gameplay mechanics, and emotional story. The reviewer highly recommends the game to anyone with even a mild interest in it.

Read full review

Video Chums

PlayStation 5

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a masterpiece of a detective game that delivers a thoroughly enjoyable open-world adventure.

Read full review

Xbox Tavern

Xbox Series X

Dec 3, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a fascinating and fantastic game for fans of Sherlock Holmes and investigative adventures. It has charm, wit, excitement, and chilling crimes. The inclusion of sensitive content raises questions about the developer's intentions, but overall, it is a thoroughly enjoyable game.

Read full review

CGMagazine

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer considers Sherlock Holmes Chapter One to be their favorite game of the year, praising its charm, elegance, and respect for Doyle's original character.

GameStar

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review suggests that the game has redeemed the series and that Sherlock Holmes fans will enjoy it.

Read full review

GameSpew

PlayStation 5

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is engaging and immersive, making the player feel like a detective. It is considered the developer's best yet.

Read full review

God is a Geek

PlayStation 5

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is an ambitious game with a fresh take on the character, offering a satisfying experience overall.

Read full review

Xbox Achievements

Xbox Series X

Nov 22, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is the most assured video game take on the literary sleuth to date, with engaging main cases, insights into Sherlock's formative years, and a firm handle on the character.

Read full review

TheXboxHub

Xbox Series X

Nov 16, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is powered by a brilliant story and offers a great dynamic with its case-solving mechanics. It provides a solid experience with some minor issues.

Read full review