Links

Amazon

Twitch

CRITIK

Mafia III

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Mafia III
Item: Mafia III
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2016

GenresAdventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, Shooter, Crime, Open World, Drama, Single Player, Racing

AvailableOct 6, 2016

PlatformXbox One, PC, PlayStation 4

DeveloperHangar 13

Overview

It’s 1968 and the rules have changed. After years in Vietnam, Lincoln Clay knows this truth: Family isn’t who you’re born with, it’s who you die for.

Elsewhere

7.0

Game analysis

Critik Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

85%

Mixed (50-79)

15%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the story of Mafia III are overwhelmingly positive. Many critics praised the story for its unique and powerful backdrop, tackling sensitive topics such as racism and violence in 1960s America. The narrative is described as engrossing, mature, and compelling, with excellent character development and emotionally anchored characters. Critics like Forbes, XboxAddict, and Easy Allies specifically highlight the story as the game's greatest strength, with Forbes calling it one of the most compelling journeys in a video game. The use of media from the time era, such as government hearing footage and present-day interviews, is also praised as a stroke of brilliance by XboxAddict. However, there are some critics who mention certain negatives about the story. Game Informer, in particular, criticizes the story for becoming a typical revenge story that dominates the narrative. Digital Spy also mentions that the story can be repetitive and by-the-numbers. Kill Screen points out that the game fails to fully explore the potential of its Southern setting and its literary aspects. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the story of Mafia III is very good. The majority of the critics praise the story for its strong writing, attention to detail, and its exploration of complex and sensitive issues such as racism and revenge. The story is described as memorable, well-presented, and well-rounded, with unique elements like a fake documentary and strong performances. The game's unflinching depiction of racism and violence in 1960s America is also highly appreciated. Critics like Guardian, DarkStation, and Push Square highlight the smart writing, superb characterization, and the game's ability to elevate a simple revenge plot. The story is considered one of the best-written in modern gaming, and its portrayal of racism is commended for being candid, unapologetic, and important.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics overwhelmingly praise Mafia III for its powerful and unique story set in 1960s America, tackling racism and violence. The narrative is described as engrossing and emotionally anchored, with excellent character development. Some critics mention negatives like repetitive elements and underexplored settings, but overall, the consensus is highly positive. The game's strong writing, attention to detail, and exploration of complex issues receive widespread acclaim, making it one of the best-written stories in modern gaming.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

81%

Negative (0-49)

16%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the gameplay of Mafia III are quite varied. Some critics have highlighted positive aspects of the gameplay, such as smooth and balanced driving mechanics, satisfying gunplay, and functional stealth options. Forbes praises the driving mechanics, while Xbox Achievements and Cheat Code Central appreciate the cover shooter mechanics. The Guardian and Hooked Gamers mention the solid combat and stealth options. These positive elements contribute to an enjoyable gameplay experience for players. However, the majority of the critics express negative opinions about the gameplay of Mafia III. The most common criticism revolves around the repetitive nature of the missions and lack of variety in gameplay activities. Game Informer, GameSpot, ZTGD, and Easy Allies all point out the repetitive missions and scenarios. The lack of variety extends to almost everything, including optional activities, according to Post Arcade. CGMagazine and DarkStation also criticize the repetitive mission design. The AI is another aspect that receives negative feedback, with GameSpot and Easy Allies mentioning dumb enemy AI as a flaw. The lack of satisfaction and creativity in the mission design is also highlighted by DarkStation and Kill Screen. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the gameplay of Mafia III has both positive and negative aspects. While there are enjoyable elements such as smooth driving mechanics and satisfying combat, the repetitive mission design and lack of variety in gameplay activities are major drawbacks. The critics emphasize the need for more creativity and depth in the missions to prevent the gameplay from becoming monotonous. Despite the mixed opinions, it is clear that the gameplay of Mafia III has not been able to fully captivate the critics, with many feeling that it falls short in comparison to other open-world crime games.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics have mixed feelings about Mafia III's gameplay. Some praise its smooth driving and satisfying combat, while others criticize its repetitive missions and lack of variety. Despite some positive aspects, like solid mechanics, the game falls short with monotonous gameplay and uninspired missions. Critics urge for more creativity to prevent it from feeling lackluster compared to other crime games.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

34%

Mixed (50-79)

55%

Negative (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Mafia III are varied. Several critics, including Forbes and COGconnected, praise the game's visuals, highlighting beautiful character design, facial animations, lighting, textures, and overall style. They appreciate the attention to detail in creating a period-perfect town of New Bordeaux, with its mix of ramshackle and commercial buildings, bayou streams, and night hotspots. The city is described as lovingly crafted and gorgeous to explore, with distinct areas such as the Bayou and the French Quarter. The inclusion of actual issues of Playboy from the 1960s is also mentioned as a positive aspect by Game Informer. On the other hand, some critics express disappointment with the graphics and visual design of Mafia III. GameSpot, Guardian, and ZTGD criticize the game for blurry textures, odd lighting, object pop-in, and visual glitches. They mention flat textures, weird lighting, and muddy visuals, particularly in the city blocks. XboxAddict and DarkStation also note that the open-world modeling is not on par with other top-tier sandbox games, and character models are unappealing. The shoddy lighting effects and inconsistent visuals are also criticized by Stevivor. Overall, the consensus among the critics is mixed. While there are positive remarks about the character design, facial animations, lighting, and the period details of New Bordeaux, there are also significant criticisms regarding blurry textures, odd lighting, visual glitches, and unappealing character models. Some critics, such as Game Informer and COGconnected, find the game visually impressive, while others, like GameSpot and ZTGD, are more critical of its graphics. However, it is worth noting that the game's visuals do not seem to have a significant impact on the overall experience for most critics. The attention to detail, authentic architecture, and culture of New Bordeaux are appreciated, but the technical flaws and inconsistent visuals detract from the overall enjoyment for some reviewers.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics have mixed opinions on Mafia III's graphics and visual design. Some praise the beautiful character design and attention to detail in creating New Bordeaux, while others criticize blurry textures, odd lighting, and visual glitches. Overall, the game's visuals receive both positive and negative feedback, with some finding them impressive while others are more critical. Despite the flaws, the game's visuals don't seem to heavily impact the overall experience for most reviewers.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

95%

Mixed (50-79)

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the sound design and music of Mafia III are overwhelmingly positive. Many critics praised the game for its exceptional soundtrack, featuring classic songs from the 1960s that create an authentic and immersive atmosphere. Critics like XboxAddict and God is a Geek specifically mentioned the quality of the music, with iconic songs from artists like Jimi Hendrix and Creedence Clearwater Revival standing out. The game's New Orleans-inspired setting and vintage '60s soundtrack were also highlighted by critics like GameSpot and Metro GameCentral for contributing to the convincing atmosphere of the game. The voice acting was another aspect that received praise, with critics like Xbox Achievements and Guardian commending the superb voice performances and convincing facial animations that bring the game's cutscenes to life. While the majority of the critics had positive opinions, there were a few negative points raised. Kill Screen criticized the game for not fully utilizing the music of New Orleans and relying on generic Motown hits and rock 'n' roll instead. Additionally, ZTGD mentioned that while the soundtrack and audio were outstanding, some NPC dialogue was repetitive, which could potentially detract from the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the sound design and music of Mafia III are exceptional. The majority of the critics praised the game's soundtrack, with many considering it one of the best in any game ever. The authentic and immersive atmosphere created by the New Orleans-inspired setting and vintage '60s soundtrack was widely appreciated. The voice acting and sound effects were also commended for blending well into the game and adding to the overall experience. While there were a few minor criticisms, the overwhelmingly positive opinions of the critics highlight the high quality of the sound design and music in Mafia III.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics raved about Mafia III's stellar sound design and music, praising its exceptional '60s soundtrack and authentic New Orleans atmosphere. Iconic songs and superb voice acting were highlighted, though some critics felt the NPC dialogue was repetitive. Overall, critics agree that Mafia III's sound is top-notch, with many considering it among the best in gaming history.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

72%

Mixed (50-79)

28%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Mafia III has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from the critics. Many critics, such as Forbes, Post Arcade, Stevivor, Xbox Achievements, ZTGD, Digital Spy, Guardian, Hooked Gamers, COGconnected, DarkStation, Easy Allies, Gaming Age, IBTimes UK, Metro GameCentral, New York Daily News, Push Square, and Washington Post, praised the voice performances in the game. They described the voice acting as well-done, top standard, incredible, first-rate, stellar, gripping, charismatic, and commendable. The critics highlighted the authenticity and believability of the voice acting, with accents, manners of speaking, and lip syncing that brought the characters to life. They also appreciated the individuality and nuance that the voice acting added to the characters. The dialogue was described as snappy and memorable, contributing to the overall immersive experience of the game. While the majority of the critics praised the voice acting in Mafia III, there were no specific negative opinions mentioned by any of the critics. However, it is important to note that one critic, Cheat Code Central, did not specifically mention the voice acting in their review, focusing instead on the authenticity of the accents in the game. This lack of mention may suggest that the voice acting did not leave a significant impression on them, but without further details, it is difficult to draw any definitive conclusions about potential negatives. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the voice acting in Mafia III is of high quality and greatly enhances the authenticity and immersion of the game. The positive reviews from multiple critics, such as Forbes, ZTGD, Easy Allies, and DarkStation, emphasize the exceptional performances and the way they bring the characters to life. The voice acting is praised for its believability, individuality, and the way it adds depth to the characters. The positive reception from the majority of the critics indicates that the voice acting in Mafia III is a standout aspect of the game and contributes significantly to the overall experience.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics unanimously praise the top-notch voice acting in Mafia III for its authenticity, believability, and immersive qualities, with accolades from multiple outlets. The performances are described as incredible, gripping, and commendable, adding depth and nuance to the characters. While one critic's lack of mention raises questions, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the exceptional quality that enhances the game's experience.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

11%

Mixed (50-79)

47%

Negative (0-49)

42%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of the technical performance on Xbox One, the majority of critics expressed concerns and encountered various issues. GameSpot, Stevivor, Xbox Achievements, XboxAddict, and ZTGD all reported experiencing bugs, crashes, visual quirks, and other technical problems. These issues ranged from broken mission objectives and enemies spotting through walls to hard crashes and odd visual glitches. However, it is worth noting that ZTGD did not encounter any major technical issues during their playtime, suggesting that the experience may vary for different players. Moving on to the PC version, Digital Spy and GameSpot both mentioned technical issues, including design oversights, broken mission objectives, enemies spotting through walls, and hard crashes. Guardian also noted visual glitches on both PS4 and PC. However, PC PowerPlay reported only a single crash on the first day, indicating a relatively smoother experience compared to other critics. It is important to consider that the PC version seemed to have a mixed reception in terms of technical performance, with some encountering significant issues while others experienced fewer problems. Regarding the PlayStation 4 version, CGMagazine, COGconnected, DarkStation, Easy Allies, GameSpot, Gameplanet, IBTimes UK, Metro GameCentral, Push Square, and Washington Post all provided feedback on the technical performance. While some critics mentioned occasional glitches, awkward physics, and control issues, others reported no significant graphical glitches or crashes. Metro GameCentral even stated that the game had fewer bugs than initially reported. However, Easy Allies found the crashes during emotional climaxes to be unacceptable, highlighting a specific concern with the game's stability on PS4. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Mafia III suffered from various technical issues across all gaming platforms. The Xbox One version seemed to have the most prevalent problems, with multiple critics mentioning bugs, crashes, visual glitches, and other technical quirks. The PC version had a mixed reception, with some critics encountering significant technical issues, while others experienced a smoother gameplay experience. The PlayStation 4 version had a range of feedback, with some critics reporting occasional glitches and control issues, while others found the technical performance to be relatively stable. It is clear that the technical performance of Mafia III was a significant concern for the majority of critics, impacting their overall experience with the game.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics across Xbox One, PC, and PlayStation 4 platforms reported various technical issues with Mafia III. Xbox One faced the most problems like bugs and crashes, while the PC version had a mixed reception. PlayStation 4 had a range of feedback, with some glitches and control issues. Overall, technical performance was a major concern for critics, affecting their gameplay experience.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

50%

Negative (0-49)

50%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of Mafia III are mixed, with some positive aspects mentioned. Xbox Achievements highlights the game's massive size and optional objectives, which can provide additional content and extend the gameplay experience. Forbes also notes that the value of replaying the game depends on the player's goals, suggesting that different playstyles and objectives can enhance the replayability for certain individuals. Additionally, COGconnected mentions the potential for post-release patches and story expansions to address the lack of mission variety, indicating that future updates may improve the replay value. However, the majority of critics express negative opinions regarding the replay value of Mafia III. GameSpot, ZTGD, Digital Spy, God is a Geek, IBTimes UK, Metro GameCentral, Push Square, and games(TM) all highlight the repetitive nature of the missions and lack of activities beyond the main story. These critics mention the uninspired mission design, lack of variety, and repetitive formula as major drawbacks that diminish the appeal of replaying the game. The review from Cheat Code Central does not specifically mention replayability but does note the lack of mission variety and suggests that the city could have had more attractions, which indirectly implies a potential negative impact on replay value. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Mafia III has limited replay value. The repetitive missions and lack of activities beyond the story missions are frequently mentioned as significant factors that diminish the appeal of replaying the game. While some positive aspects, such as the game's size and optional objectives, are highlighted by a few critics, the negative opinions regarding the lack of variety and repetitive gameplay overshadow these positives. It is clear that the majority of critics feel that Mafia III falls short in terms of providing a compelling experience for repeated playthroughs.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics are divided on Mafia III's replay value. Some praise its size and optional objectives while others criticize its repetitive missions and lack of variety. The game's appeal for replay largely depends on individual preferences and playstyles. Future updates may address some issues, but overall, critics agree that Mafia III lacks compelling reasons for multiple playthroughs.

Overall Verdict

CRITIK

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Critik Score

Positive (80-100)

14%

Mixed (50-79)

83%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

Overall, the opinions of the critics regarding the Overall Verdict of Mafia III are quite mixed. There are several positive aspects of the game that are consistently mentioned by the reviewers. The strong storytelling and narrative are praised by multiple critics, such as Forbes, Stevivor, and Cheat Code Central. The game is commended for its compelling story, well-executed delivery, and authentic portrayal of important themes like racism and cultural fault lines (NZGamer, Washington Post). The visuals and setting of the game are also highlighted as positives, with critics like Xbox Achievements and Hooked Gamers mentioning the remarkable rendition of 1960s America and the wonderful setting of New Bordeaux. On the negative side, there are several criticisms that are commonly raised by the reviewers. The gameplay is often criticized for being repetitive, unimaginative, and unoriginal (Game Informer, GameSpot, Post Arcade). The mission design is described as poor and the combat as generic and repetitive (Digital Spy, Hooked Gamers). Technical issues, glitches, and lack of polish are also mentioned as drawbacks (XboxAddict, DarkStation). The lack of variety in gameplay and side missions is another common criticism (Cheat Code Central). Some critics, like Game Informer and Metro GameCentral, go as far as describing the game as a missed opportunity and a waste of a strong narrative. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that Mafia III has a strong story and narrative, but it falls short in other areas. The positive aspects of the game, such as the compelling story, authentic portrayal of important themes, and remarkable visuals, are acknowledged by multiple reviewers. However, the negative aspects, including repetitive and unoriginal gameplay, technical issues, lack of variety, and poor mission design, are also consistently mentioned. While some critics recommend the game for its strong narrative despite its flaws (Stevivor), others consider it a disappointment that fails to fully capitalize on its potential (Guardian, Metro GameCentral). The overall sentiment seems to be that Mafia III has its strengths, particularly in terms of storytelling, but it is held back by its gameplay and technical issues.

TL;DR

Critics have mixed opinions on Mafia III. They praise its strong storytelling, authentic themes, and visuals, but criticize its repetitive gameplay, poor mission design, and technical issues. While some recommend it for its narrative, others see it as a missed opportunity that fails to reach its full potential. Mafia III shines in storytelling but falls short in gameplay and execution, leaving room for improvement.

CRITIK

Reviews

124 reviews found

Gaming Age

PlayStation 4

Oct 17, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III has its flaws, but it has enough good elements to make it hard to stay mad at the game.

Read full review

Forbes

Xbox One

Oct 9, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III is a game with a strong story and visuals, but the gameplay may not be as innovative or groundbreaking. It is recommended for those who enjoy character studies and are not solely focused on gameplay mechanics.

Games(TM)

PlayStation 4

Nov 8, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises Mafia III as the smartest and most original sandbox game in years, with a cohesive story about a young black man waging war against white institutions. It considers the game a small miracle given the current condition of big videogames.

NZGamer

PlayStation 4

Oct 19, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III is praised for its authentic and honest portrayal of racism, making it an important game despite its flaws. People of color have praised its handling of the subject matter, although not everyone agrees with its heavy-handedness.

Washington Post

PlayStation 4

Oct 27, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game tackles cultural fault lines and reminds the reviewer to expect more from video games. Despite some flaws, the reviewer was invested in the story and characters.

Xbox Achievements

Xbox One

Oct 10, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A decent open-world game, despite its myriad issues and repetitious mission structure, Mafia 3 excels as a cover shooter and epic crime saga. The problems with the game are outweighed by how enjoyable it is to play, with its robust driving and combat, and remarkable rendition of 1960s America.

Read full review

COGconnected

PlayStation 4

Oct 13, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III is a good game with a compelling story and engaging combat, despite some minor issues.

Read full review

Hooked Gamers

Oct 24, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III is an enjoyable game with a wonderful setting, a perfectly matched soundtrack, and solid combat mechanics. However, the generic enemy designs and repetitive combat can be drawbacks.

Read full review

XboxAddict

Xbox One

Oct 20, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Mafia III has a superb story and delivery, but is held back by glitches and lack of polish. With improved visuals and bug fixes, it could contend with bigger games. However, as it stands, it falls short of being a top contender.

Read full review

ZTGD

Xbox One

Oct 14, 2016

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite its flaws, Mafia III is praised as having one of the best stories in a video game this year. The memorable world and engaging story make it worth checking out.

Read full review